Ohhh, the evolution of finger sucking. For Malcom it began as full fists, then his first two fingers, and just recently settling on his thumbs. Sure it's cute to watch him comfort himself in this way, but it concerns me... will he have to go through what I went through to be able to stop it?
To say that I was an avid thumb sucker would be an understatement. I am told it began shortly after I made my debut into this world, and
ended.... well the fact that I can remember desperately trying to stop the sleep-habit should tell you something...
I must have been around the age of 4 or 5 when my parents decided that I needed an intervention. "Too old!" they said- but what they really meant was they were worried that I would eventually become an adult thumb-sucker in college, with roommates, and a possible audience via video tape or polaroid.
My parents had warned me that I needed to end the habit, but I remember the bewilderment of my young self trying to understand how one could possibly kick a habit that she had no idea she was doing... in her sleep?! They warned of the more "real" intervention measures, which I assume came shortly thereafter.
"Vicki- go get a screwdriver from the toolbox." my dad commanded one evening shortly

before bedtime. Something about the way his eyes twinkled and the snickers of my four older siblings sparked an ominous warning in my mind. I did as he asked, picking a random black handled phillips and handing it back to him. Dad then took one of my hands, and commenced to duct tape the screwdriver to my thumb. My siblings and parents all laughed at my new plight, which was how not to wack myself in my face while sleeping... it's always funnier when it's not you..
Once that proved more unpleasant than helpful, we progressed to a plentiful smothering of super hot sauce on each thumb. That became too messy, and I believe I was
put through a few more torturous flaming hoops before my parents must have given up and figured I'd grow out of it. I just remember waking in the wee hours of the morning, horrified, realizing I was

sucking that traitorous thumb again and looking around to make sure no one was watching. Then I'd lay on my hands, trying to stay just awake to catch myself doing in the act. That didn't work either.
I believe I also tried tying my hands to the bedposts, which also didn't work so well for three reasons:
1. It's hard to tie up one hand once the other is already tied.
2. You're arms fall asleep after a few minutes, and by morning you worry that you'll never be able to use them again.
3. If you do last till morning, you realize that you're arms are dead and useless and you have to wait for someone to miss you, then come looking for you. I was the youngest of five, with a house full of cats and dogs and fish. Waiting for someone to come looking for me could potentially take hours...
I don't know when or how I kicked the thumb-sucking habit. I must have at some point because if I still did, Ben would tease me mercilessly... I am thankful for my parents' intervention on my behalf as well. Though their methods didn't initially solve the problem, my fear of their methods must have helped...
I don't know if I'd be overly concerned if Malcom sucks his thumb longer than most children, but if worse comes to worst, than I believe the hand-tying method could be improved on with a little outside help. :)
Fun links: